This page presents ideas submitted by other users like you, in response to QHSR study group proposals on the 'Smart and Tough Enforcement of Immigration Laws' topic. On this page, you can:

  • Find the best ideas to rate and tag, using the sorting buttons and Discussion Tags below
  • Find ideas about topics that interest you using the search function, and rate and tag those ideas
  • If something important to you has not already been submitted, use the “Submit an Idea” button to add your own suggestion to the list

All ideas

  1. Goals

    by gwolfe from Railroad Sector Coordinating Counsel (RSCC) on August 10, 2009 at 09:51AM

    Eliminate confusion between the various government agencies involved in enforcing immigration laws. This confusion is due in part to the lack of communication between the various agencies.

    Current tags

      Votes so far

      Currently 0.0 Stars.
      0.0 (0 votes - averaged)
      Read and Rate
    • Goal

      by gwolfe from Railroad Sector Coordinating Counsel (RSCC) on August 09, 2009 at 07:59PM

      Eliminate confusion between the various government agencies involved in enforcing immigration laws. This confusion is due in part to the lack of communication between the various agencies.

      Current tags

        Votes so far

        Currently 0.0 Stars.
        0.0 (0 votes - averaged)
        Read and Rate
      • foriegn aid

        by cluckhut from self on August 09, 2009 at 07:40PM

        How about we enforce the laws we have & if someone wants to come here they will do what is needed to do so! ( learn the language, pay taxes & swear allegiance to the USA! ) Also instead of spendin...

        Current tags

          Votes so far

          Currently 0.0 Stars.
          0.0 (0 votes - averaged)
          Read and Rate
        • Fixing the immigration system

          by fosorio from individual on August 09, 2009 at 04:41PM

          My idea would be to eliminate the backlogs to enable persons to obtain legal status instead of forcing illegal immigration,The current wait time for a I-601 waiver is 15 months,thaere has to be a ...

          Current tags

            Votes so far

            Currently 0.0 Stars.
            0.0 (0 votes - averaged)
            Read and Rate
          • Family Unity is Key to Integration

            by jsmyers from Church World Service on August 07, 2009 at 01:00PM

            Family unity should be the cornerstone of our immigration policies, and family-based visas should be increased, allowed to rollover to the next fiscal year, and the backlog should be reduced. The ...

            Current tags

            Votes so far

            Currently 4.28571428571 Stars.
            4.2 (7 votes - averaged)
            Read and Rate
          • Family Unity

            by hdominguez from American Families United on August 06, 2009 at 10:59PM

            Make Family Unity a priority Normally a foreign national who is married to a U.S. citizen can file to "adjust" his/her status in the United States to become a permanent resident ("green card" h...

            Votes so far

            Currently 3.25 Stars.
            3.2 (12 votes - averaged)
            Read and Rate
          • A home and some respect for the homeless

            by longshot9999 from FastBreed Technologies, Inc. on August 06, 2009 at 08:07PM

            Maybe we should create villages for the homeless along the border and pay them to keep an eye out for illegal aliens. This would give them a free place to stay, centralized points for charities to...

            Current tags

              Votes so far

              Currently 1.0 Stars.
              1.0 (5 votes - averaged)
              Read and Rate
            • Comments

              by epluribusunum from Self on August 06, 2009 at 10:19AM

              Comemnts On Mission Statement: Add a reference to the current Immigration Act Comments On Goals: Goal 1 - Change "to the right person at the right time" to "to persons as defined...

              Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 2.75 Stars.
                2.7 (4 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Mixed families

                by averydulles from Adult Basic Education on August 06, 2009 at 02:45AM

                Something needs to be done to deal with the US children of immigrants. I don't think it's right to make them leave with the parents who are here without documentation. This is a great hardship for...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.23076923077 Stars.
                3.2 (13 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Mission Vision Statement

                by Izzy from Language Access Consultants LLC on August 05, 2009 at 11:42PM

                Not only should an immigration system protect the public but it should also protect the civil rights of ALL person regardless of immigration status and national origin. Equal protection and proper...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.8125 Stars.
                3.8 (16 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Immigration

                by donbahlsj from Kino Border Inittiative on August 05, 2009 at 07:42PM

                The phenomenon of immigration is a global issue. It is an international reality. Much of our national focus should also take into consideration this universal aspect. Thus we need to consider the ...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.64285714286 Stars.
                3.6 (14 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Immigrant benefits?

                by zerotolerance from entertainment on August 05, 2009 at 05:54PM

                Goal #1 needs to tighten up. "Effectively and efficiently...right person at the right time." What does that mean? That is so broad that I can see loopholes from my house! Illegal immigrants could ...

                Votes so far

                Currently 2.26315789474 Stars.
                2.2 (19 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Border educator

                by orozcor from Cochise College on August 05, 2009 at 05:38PM

                Any policy must remove the incentives for illegal immigration. It must also have flexibility to allow for timely response to reasonable requests for legal entry.

                Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.25 Stars.
                3.2 (12 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Enforcement

                by fred0245 from None on August 04, 2009 at 04:29PM

                Ever since the formation of DHS and the decommission of INS, enforcement is down. The creation of CBP & ICE offered great potential to strike an effective blow against illegal aliens, not just tho...

                Votes so far

                Currently 2.73684210526 Stars.
                2.7 (19 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Mission should be stronger

                by dstitt from Mecklenburg County Sheriff's Office on August 04, 2009 at 11:35AM

                The mission should be to enhance safety and security of all communities by creating partnerships to address issues of a strong immigration policy.

                Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.0 Stars.
                3.0 (7 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Uniformity

                by brolove from Security Consultant ETC on August 04, 2009 at 07:48AM

                Uniformity , there should be uniformed immigration guide lines and checks, so that the same immigration rules apply to everyone at every boarder; without respect of National origin, sex, or religi...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.0 Stars.
                3.0 (12 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Bring Back Discretion

                by tklinke from Small Law Firm on August 04, 2009 at 12:40AM

                It seems as though DHS only looks for ways to keep people out of the United States, not at how to keep families together, or keep other deserving individuals in this country. Talented individuals ...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.55172413793 Stars.
                3.5 (29 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • End Detention for Non-Violent Undocumented Workers

                by tklinke from Small Law Firm on August 04, 2009 at 12:06AM

                Undocumented immigrants who are arrested for immigration violations should not be placed in detention facilities if they have little or no criminal history. Instead, place them on orders of superv...

                Votes so far

                Currently 3.1724137931 Stars.
                3.1 (29 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Enforcement of Immigration Laws

                by japowers from Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security on August 03, 2009 at 07:04PM

                This would be an adequate Vision Statement were it not for the last 2 phrases (e.g., "enriches our society, and improves our economy.") Neither of these goals/objectives are within the DHS char...

                Current tags

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 2.53846153846 Stars.
                  2.5 (13 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Reconsider Effect of 287g and Raids on Families and Communities

                  by jlyall from Catholic Charities of Los Angeles on August 03, 2009 at 04:59PM

                  DHS should reconsider the effect its enforcement policies are having on families and communities, particularly low-income communities of color. What is frequently billed as a "partnership between ...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 3.59459459459 Stars.
                  3.5 (37 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Clarity Needed on Goals 2 and 3

                  by sbrubinson from JohnsonDiversey Inc. on August 03, 2009 at 03:02PM

                  It would be helpful to have clarification on goals 2 and 3. In goal 2, what are the conditions that allow illegal immigration to occur, and in what ways can DHS address whatever the underlying con...

                  Current tags

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.0 Stars.
                  4.0 (11 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Encourage-discourage?

                  by rleavell from Seattle Police Department on August 02, 2009 at 06:05PM

                  It's not within the HLS purview to encourage or discourage legal immigration (see goal 4). Rather the HLS mission is to enforce the laws of our nation in a safe, legal, ethical and effective manner.

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 3.23076923077 Stars.
                  3.2 (13 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Not clear on "improves economy"

                  by rstein from DHS on August 01, 2009 at 07:10PM

                  Is "improves economy" referring to attracting productive members of society who can make a difference economically (e.g new taxpayers) or attracting entrepreneurs who will seek to start businesses ...

                  Current tags

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 3.8 Stars.
                  3.8 (5 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Comprehensive legislative reform

                  by Jorge from U.S. Customs and Border Protection on August 01, 2009 at 12:30PM

                  Unfortunately, I think that it is beyond DHS's ability to make the structural changes that will truly be needed to fix the incentives that encourage illegal migration. The INA is, quite simply, a ...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 3.81818181818 Stars.
                  3.8 (22 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Compassionate

                  by yche1 from Naval Postgraduate School - Center for Homeland Defense & Security on July 31, 2009 at 03:51PM

                  While "secure, fair, adaptative" are good terms to have in such a policy, so is having a compassionate immigration policy that underscores our nation's embrace of individuals who encounter exigent ...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.125 Stars.
                  4.1 (32 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate