This page presents ideas submitted by other users like you, in response to 'QHSR study group proposals on the Counterterrorism and Domestic Security' topic. On this page, you can:

  • Find the best ideas to rate and tag, using the sorting buttons and Discussion Tags below
  • Find ideas about topics that interest you using the search function, and rate and tag those ideas
  • If something important to you has not already been submitted, use the “Submit an Idea” button to add your own suggestion to the list

All ideas

  1. Vision Statement Revision

    by fschwien from The Boeing Company on August 05, 2009 at 09:14PM

    The second sentence in the vision statement makes no sense. We do not prevent terrorist attacks by "providing active leadership, removing barriers, etc." Being engaged with both the public and pri...

    Votes so far

    Currently 5.0 Stars.
    5.0 (11 votes - averaged)
    Read and Rate
  2. Aspiration vs. goal

    by mclark470 from Modine Manufacturing Company on August 05, 2009 at 07:59PM

    The "goals" look more like aspirations than goals to me. To borrow from project management vernacular, goals should be SMART: Specific Measurable Attainable Realistic Time-based ...

    Votes so far

    Currently 5.0 Stars.
    5.0 (9 votes - averaged)
    Read and Rate
  3. Coordinated regional response/assistance

    by bgeorge from Pasadena police Department on August 07, 2009 at 04:14PM

    We should ensure that organizations are training for a coordinated/consistent response to a major incident with their allied/partnering agencies.

    Current tags

      Votes so far

      Currently 5.0 Stars.
      5.0 (3 votes - averaged)
      Read and Rate
    • better integration with critical small businesses

      by TomTalks from National Security Grid on August 07, 2009 at 02:34AM

      "providing incentives for the sustained engagement..." does not capture the breadth of activity the DHS needs to undertake in order to fulfill this mission statement. While the DHS and related Fed...

      Votes so far

      Currently 5.0 Stars.
      5.0 (2 votes - averaged)
      Read and Rate
    • Mission Vision

      by marty from Sacramento Sheriff on August 02, 2009 at 03:28PM

      The mission vision for Borders is short and to the point like this one should be

      Current tags

        Votes so far

        Currently 5.0 Stars.
        5.0 (1 vote - averaged)
        Read and Rate
      • retired law enforcement

        by waltp7 from state gov on August 05, 2009 at 08:42PM

        Many Federal LE positions have a cut-off for hireing at 37 years of age, because of retirement issues, etc. Create a new catagory in order to hire some of the thousands of trained law enforcement ...

        Votes so far

        Currently 4.91666666667 Stars.
        4.9 (12 votes - averaged)
        Read and Rate
      • expectation re: preventing terrorism

        by nmorag from Center for Homeland Defense and Security, Naval Postgraduate School on July 31, 2009 at 03:41PM

        If we look at the Israeli and British approaches, there is no expectation that terrorism can be entirely prevented because that is recognized as being an unrealistic goal. If we are to move away f...

        Votes so far

        Currently 4.75 Stars.
        4.7 (12 votes - averaged)
        Read and Rate
      • FPS Portal

        by comodt from Hennepin County Sheriff's Office, Minneapolis, MN on August 07, 2009 at 10:37PM

        The FPS Portal is a wonerful tool for facilitating interagency communications.

        Current tags

          Votes so far

          Currently 4.5 Stars.
          4.5 (2 votes - averaged)
          Read and Rate
        • Natural Hazards

          by richmonk from Michigan State Police / EMHSD on August 05, 2009 at 05:59PM

          Remove natural hazards from this section. Natural hazards are not applicable to counterterrorism and domestic security management.While many homeland security capabilities are all-hazards applicab...

          Current tags

            Votes so far

            Currently 4.46153846154 Stars.
            4.4 (13 votes - averaged)
            Read and Rate
          • Need to separate into distinct mission areas

            by skfisher from California Judiciary on August 01, 2009 at 09:42PM

            Counterterrorism and domestic security management are distinct missions, albeit with several important overlapping goals and values. By separating the two, each mission can be made stronger and mo...

            Current tags

              Votes so far

              Currently 4.41666666667 Stars.
              4.4 (12 votes - averaged)
              Read and Rate
            • Lack of coordination

              by cordner from Kutztown University on August 05, 2009 at 06:26PM

              Three of these goals indicate they are shared with Disasters (planning for ... responding to ...). However, they don't show up over under the Disasters tab. Suggests a lack of coordination.

              Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 4.33333333333 Stars.
                4.3 (3 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Board Member

                by mubmirjat from UMAA ( Shia Muslim Organization) on August 04, 2009 at 07:51PM

                We need to have out standing, unbiased review of the application people are applying to come to United States and any one coming with immigration Visa need to be fairly delt. Fairness is the on...

                Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 4.33333333333 Stars.
                4.3 (3 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Alternative CT Mission Statement

                by DJACHQ from n/a on August 06, 2009 at 03:24AM

                ALTERNATIVE CT MISSION STATEMENT SUGGESTION: TO MOBILIZE A CONCERTED AMERICAN EFFORT TO COUNTER TERRORISM OR OTHER DELIBERATE ACTS OF DESTRUCTION OR SOCIETAL SABOTAGE IN ORDER TO PROTECT THE C...

                Votes so far

                Currently 4.33333333333 Stars.
                4.3 (3 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Whose goals are these?

                by cb97424 from Naval Postgraduate School on July 31, 2009 at 05:07PM

                Eliminate goals that are not related to preventing and responding to terrorism. Include goals that clarify homeland security needs to collaborate with the agencies and functions that are related t...

                Current tags

                Votes so far

                Currently 4.28571428571 Stars.
                4.2 (7 votes - averaged)
                Read and Rate
              • Supply chain

                by cdreibel from Reform Institute on August 05, 2009 at 04:56PM

                Although it is implied in goal 2, hardening the supply chain should be an explicit goal.

                Current tags

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.25 Stars.
                  4.2 (4 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Comments

                  by epluribusunum from Self on August 06, 2009 at 10:03AM

                  General Comments on Mission Statement: Add a statement to ensure operations are conducted within all federal, state and local regulations and that all rights and privledges provided US citiz...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.2 Stars.
                  4.2 (5 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • Man Made Hazards

                  by pjcoyle from Chemical Facility Security News on August 03, 2009 at 03:39PM

                  The euphemism 'Man Made Hazards' as used in Goal 4 is very misleading. DHS does not have responsibility for preventing most of the real man made hazards that face our society. Global warming, toxi...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.18181818182 Stars.
                  4.1 (11 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • The vision could be more memorable

                  by cb97424 from Naval Postgraduate School on July 31, 2009 at 04:21PM

                  My idea is to rework the vision statement so it offers a clear and memorable vision. For example: "We want to prevent terrorist attacks." I do not think the proposed vision statement can "mobil...

                  Votes so far

                  Currently 4.16666666667 Stars.
                  4.1 (12 votes - averaged)
                  Read and Rate
                • We must ake a strong distinction between malicious actors versus normal citizen protest. There is a current movement to demonize those who just diagree with the administration. This is totally dif...

                  Current tags

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.16666666667 Stars.
                    4.1 (6 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Mission Vision Statement

                    by eimhof from Contra Costa County, Office of the Sheriff on August 03, 2009 at 12:07AM

                    What are other attacks? Providing incentives; does this refer to grants? If not what does this refer to? Under Goals: #3 Prevent illicit access to and movement of materials and capabilitie...

                    Current tags

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.16666666667 Stars.
                    4.1 (6 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Alternative CT Vision

                    by CatRanSauce from CHDS-Naval Postgraduate School on August 01, 2009 at 07:15PM

                    Make it shorter, to the point, and free of what Peter Drucker calls a hero sandwich of good intentions, since natural disasters area out of the purview of counterterrorism and security management. ...

                    Current tags

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.14285714286 Stars.
                    4.1 (7 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Mission "creep"

                    by rleavell from Seattle Police Department on August 02, 2009 at 05:15PM

                    Concur that the mission is not consistent with the title to the extent that it addresses natural disasters. Those references should be transfered to the Disasters section. Also, we would be bet...

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.09090909091 Stars.
                    4.0 (11 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • another goal

                    by rocco from gryphon scientific/ NPS-CHDS on August 02, 2009 at 05:29PM

                    One of the goals should be to recognize that all other goals must be sought only in the context of preserving the personal freedoms and civil liberties that we cherish in the US.

                    Current tags

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.08333333333 Stars.
                    4.0 (12 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • America will be judged by how she treats the most vulnerable of her citizens

                    by gfhughes from Hughes Magnetics on August 04, 2009 at 09:04PM

                    Homeland security must be balanced against American citizen's loss of freedoms, and minority citizens are the most vulnerable. DHS should cooperate with our general aviation association, AOPA, wo...

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.0 Stars.
                    4.0 (10 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • CT Vision Statement

                    by RPMueck from University of Maryland Dept of Public Safety on August 03, 2009 at 03:54PM

                    The vision statement is well intentioned but wordy. Phrases like "mobilizing American effort" and "assure resilience" are not reasonable, though laudable. May I recommend that there be a vision st...

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.0 Stars.
                    4.0 (6 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Food Defense

                    by sreddy2009 from USDA FSIS ODIFP on August 04, 2009 at 05:40PM

                    Contamination of food with toxic chemicals and harmful pathogens with an intent to inflict mass illnesses and death should be considered an important aspect of modern day terrorsm. With increasing...

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.0 Stars.
                    4.0 (5 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Why human rights matter

                    by jwalsh from UNC Charlotte on August 07, 2009 at 02:43PM

                    "Efforts to achieve these objectives must always respect human rights. Human rights are an integral and valuable part of the American political tradition. Respecting human rights--especially the r...

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.0 Stars.
                    4.0 (2 votes - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Smart tradeoffs

                    by JDLH from Self on August 07, 2009 at 04:30AM

                    Insert the phrase "smart tradeoffs" or similar wording in the Counterterrorism "mission vision" statement, and/or the goals. Use it as a conjunction between conflicting goals, such as "Counter ter...

                    Current tags

                    Votes so far

                    Currently 4.0 Stars.
                    4.0 (1 vote - averaged)
                    Read and Rate
                  • Glossary/definitions section

                    by lthomas from University of Findlay on August 07, 2009 at 12:15AM

                    I think it might be helpful to have a definitions section or glossary of each major term for the mission and goals.

                    Current tags

                      Votes so far

                      Currently 4.0 Stars.
                      4.0 (1 vote - averaged)
                      Read and Rate
                    • Mission or motto – tomatoe or tomato

                      by jrollins from CHDS on August 02, 2009 at 02:46AM

                      I am a simpleton and I like things simple. I want to be able to wake up in the middle of the night and have my fellow homeland security professionals wake up and be able to precisely recite a simpl...

                      Votes so far

                      Currently 3.83333333333 Stars.
                      3.8 (12 votes - averaged)
                      Read and Rate